Monday, September 22, 2008

People I could hang out with

My senior year of college I was invited to be part of a national student delegation to the country of Kuwait. A week or so before I received that invitation, I found out I had been accepted to graduate school at Georgetown University with a full tuition scholarship. As our delegation was meeting in Washington DC for a week of briefings before heading to Kuwait, I went a few days earlier to visit the place I assumed I would be spending the next several years of my life.

The waiting room for my graduate program was lined with cherrywood paneling and upholstered in arabesque print. I remember worrying that my wet, squishy tennis shoes would somehow dirty the place after walking in from the April rain. I stayed the night with a recent alum from my hole-in-the-wall state university, but the next day headed to a posh DC hotel where we student delegates were to stay during the Washington leg of our journey.

It was the first time I'd ever hailed a cab. And I was surprised when a guy in a uniform picked up my suitcase as I checked in. I'd never been to a hotel with a bell hop before. The nicest place I'd ever stayed before that was at a Red Lion with a bunch of girls from my church youth group when we attended a winter youth festival. The bell hop led me to the room, opened the door, set my luggage on a rack, opened the curtains, and then stood at the door awkwardly for a few seconds. Was I supposed to tip him? Or was that just something they did on television but not in real life? The bell hop had mercy on me and left quickly. I felt terribly out of place in this new, fancy world I'd found myself in. And I tell you the truth, dear reader, I broke out into tears as I sat on the immaculate bed.

That is how I feel when I read most erotica.

But I didn't realize it until I read Jacqueline Applebee's story "What I do for my pain." When blogger friend Pandora mentioned that Ms. Applebee's erotica included disabled characters, I pictured blond girls dressed in hip retro dresses sitting in specially-designed wheelchairs -- you know, people with real disabilities, as opposed to someone like me with amorphous pain disorders and controversial multi-systemic diseases.

I was so wrong.

There was no mention of stylish clothes or hip apartments in the city or parties with canapes or exotic furniture where two people with perfect bodies have perfectly aligned sex.

No, instead I was met with a character who bumps into her lover's boob in bed. Who has enough flesh that it can be kneaded. Who wants a tattoo that looks like a sunflower. And whose disability was chronic period pain.

See, I'm clumsy in bed too (among other places). And have plenty of flesh to kneed. I don't know that I can get a tattoo now that I'm on anticoagulants, but if I were to ever get one, it'd probably be something cheery like a sunflower too. And boy do I know what chronic period pain is like as everyone of my periods since I started having them when I was ten years old have been dreadful.

Sometimes it’s a constant cracking against the back of my spine, sometimes it’s a top note sung by a soprano, but held against my groin for sixteen hours. Medication doesn’t seem to help, and heaven knows I’ve tried most of the alternatives.

It sounds a bit silly, but I started crying a little when I read that bit. I just never hear anybody ever talk about the ordeal that painful periods can be -- you know, outside of pamphlets from the doctor's office. And I certainly haven't see someone validate that experience by making it the primary conflict in a story. But it wasn't just a story, it was a damn sexy story.

As I continued reading, I found that this was a character I could so see myself hanging out with. Exchanging medical horror stories or sharing the alternative that has finally worked for me (Red Raspberry leaf tea, as impossible as that may be to believe, considering how exquisite the pain).

And that, that was when it suddenly dawned on me that I don't ever imagine myself hanging out with the characters in the erotica I generally read. Part of that comes down to just how effective Ms. Applebee is in creating such realistic characters. But a lot of it is that characters in erotica intimidate the hell out of me.

I'm not stylish. I'm five feet tall and fat. The last pieces of clothing I bought were a sensible white Playtex bra on sale this month online, a red shirt and a pair of jeans on sale at Walmart about a year ago, and a t-shirt from the Goodwill several months before that. I only own three pairs of shoes (that accommodate my orthotics). So, you know, no skin tight dresses or several hundred dollar fuck me shoes here.

I do live in a studio downtown, but I live in HUD housing with seniors and the disabled which sorta takes away any sort of glamour from the whole living in the city thing. And my part of the city is where the meth freaks and pimps hang out, though personally, I like the color they add to the neighborhood.

Being on Food Stamps means that canapes are never on the menu here, though I do make the best chocolate chip cookies ever. And Two-Buck-Chuck is about the only wine you'll find in my kitchen -- and then only when A. is here because I can't really drink much wine anymore.

Erotica is all about fantasy and so it is understandable that it will reflect what is most perfect in our society. Writing -- erotica or otherwise -- requires a certain level of education to both attain the skills necessary to create worlds on paper (or computer), as well as the ability to think originally about topics, particularly ones that are mostly taboo. And most of those who get that education come from a base socio-economic level and higher. It's hard to think and write about sex when, say, you just barely finished high school and you're trying to figure out how to pay the rent on your trailer despite working four jobs (a common predicament in my family).

I remember years ago listening to essayist Richard Rodriguez on the NewsHour talk about how little poverty makes it into our literature (aside from the Bohemian sort). That we needed people to write about the experience of being poor in the same way that writers such as Toni Morrison have talked about the experience of being African-American or how he had written about being Latino.

I remember thinking at the time, hey, I could do that. I know what it's like to grow up poor. Thanks to an illness which has left me incapable of doing any job in the national economy (as the vocational expert testified at my disability hearing), I still get to know what it's like to be poor.

And if Jacqueline Applebee can write hot, sexy erotica about chronic period pain, well damnit, I should be writing hot, sexy erotica about poor, fat, sick people.

You know, people I could totally hang out with...


10 comments:

Haron said...

I want to print this post out and hang it on the wall. (Also, I wish I could hang out with you in person and discuss it, but then I usually feel like that.)

I've never been able to exactly put my finger on why most erotica actively irks me. And I've never quite known what I was trying to achieve in my own writing, without articulating it. This is exactly it: I may want an escapist fantasy, but it has to be an escapist fantasy about the sort of people who I don't feel would dismiss me with a wave and go back to their canapes.

Thanks for writing this, dear. I'll go away and ponder it now.

Paul said...

Natty, a good post, there are more people that you can hang out with than you can shake a fish at, should you want to,that is.
I run an alternative health clinic, 40 to 50% of our clients have M E, Fibro-myalgia, I D S, many of them are as you describe yourself.
I write a little erotica, but it's fantasy and usually placed in the past.
Your point is very valid, thank you.
Warm hugs,
Paul.

Lele said...

Amazing post, thank you.

I've missed you and your blog so much! (been out of the country)

I look forward to reading some of your 'real life' erotica, but in the meantime, I'm definitely going to check into this Jacqueline Applebee.

Take care!

Jacqueline Applebee said...

Wow! Thank you so much for this. I'm tickled to bits that others can both enjoy and identify with my stories. You may also enjoy "Punk Pizza Day" on my website (Vegan Punks get down and dirty)

I used to feel alienated from a lot of fiction in general and erotica in particular. Everyone seemed blonde, young, wealthy and American. I'm overjoyed that a black British bisexual working class woman with a disability could make a connection with you.

Kind regards
J. Applebee
http://www.writing-in-shadows.co.uk
Breaking down barriers with smut.

Jigsaw Analogy said...

this is a REALLY good post, as the others have said.

I felt terribly out of place in this new, fancy world I'd found myself in.

that part really resonated with me. for me, it wasn't just the sense of not fitting in with the college folks, but then, on going home, of fitting in less there, too. (mind you, part of this is because i went to fancy pants private colleges. but with my family, anything but community college was gonna make me out of place.)

Being on Food Stamps means that canapes are never on the menu here, though I do make the best chocolate chip cookies ever.

you *do* realize that canapes are mostly just regular food, in smaller pieces, right? of course, with ME/CFS, it's not like you often have the energy to stand around cooking much. and lacking a live-in partner like w, it's not like you have someone who actually ENJOYS the finicky prep work.


as for the erotica... i don't think i'd ever really noticed, maybe because i'm so used to not "fitting in" when i read books. there just aren't that many books of *any* kind about biracial, disabled, grew up poor but somehow wound up middle class as adults, previously abused but somehow wound up in a healthy adult relationship, people who are multiple.

i'd totally read your erotica, should you choose to write it. and when i'm not sitting around waiting for my landlord to show up, i'll check out jacqueline applebee's stuff, too.

A.S.S. said...

Spanking erotica seems to be a little better as far as being 'real world'... at least what we tend to read (probably because it's written by unpaid bloggers)... than other kinds of erotica.

Maybe some like that escape. But we're with you... that fantasy can be had while still offering real feeling characters.

Really enjoyed your post.

:)
Todd and Suzy

marianne said...

I've thought many times that sex blog land is a very privileged place... very white bread, educated, socio-economically easy, overall. That concerns me. Yet, it's still a broader spectrum than my 'real' life, and one where there are more people who share my interests. Life is weird. And this was beautifully expressed. Well done.

Oh, and chronic period pain? Me too. Red Raspberry Leaf tea, eh? I shall try. I've been on and off so many pill prescriptions over the years, with little success.

Natty said...

Haron -- Thanks. I wish we could hang out too. I miss hanging out with people aside from medical professions. ;-)

Paul -- Thanks. Yes, there are plenty of people with "invisible illnesses" but I miss seeing them in erotica. And while I don't know about your erotica, I find that historical erotica -- including spanking erotica -- the characters are often wealthy and most certainly able-bodied.

Lele -- Heya! I keep meaning to send you an email to find out whatchya been up to and as you know, I'm terrible at ever getting around to email (it doesn't help that I'm only awake and online for four hours a day anymore). Thanks so much for your comments and it's great to hear from you!

Jacqueline -- While I'm not black, British or bisexual (aside from the odd fantasy here and there), I am working class -- or rather grew up between working class and the underclass -- and disabled so there is still much for me to relate to in your writing. Not to mention you do a great job at creating very real characters!

JA -- Maybe it's because, aside from my freshman year and my first year of grad school, I was generally close to my family during college that kept me from feeling less out of place. I think when I really felt it most keenly was probably when I returned from Georgetown, but I think my differences with my family were always...complicated and started well before college. But had I spent four years at Georgetown, I think it really would have created a lot more distance and discomfort when I visited.

As for canapes, it's true, they often are made of staple foods, but my understanding is that traditionally they were and often are topped with items such as caviar, smoked salmon, etc., depending on the guests.

Todd and Suzy - Thanks. While blogged erotica isn't maybe as egregious as published erotica, I think there is still quite a lot of socio-economic specific references in the spanking blogosphere. Being someone who isn't even working class (much less middle or upper class) does makes me particularly sensitive.

Marianne -- Yes, it's true that there still remains a lot of diversity within sex blog land, to the point where I'm often taken aback when, say, I suddenly hear people rail against prostitution. ;-)

As for the Red Raspberry leaf tea, it's not perfect. I still cramp and feel quite uncomfortable the week before and during my period. But it's not the horrific, curl up in the fetal position and wish for death event that it used to be. I get loose-leaf raspberry leaves from an herb shop here in town and steep for a good hour with some lemon balm and other herbs like Pineapple Mint and/or Siberian Ginseng and Astragalus to help with the hit to my immune system.

Anonymous said...

I don't have a blog. In fact I'm quite new to the concept. I discovered Urban Gypsy's by accident a few months back...since then I have followed trails to other writers and been fascinated, moved, humbled, turned on (obviously) and a myriad of other emotions and feelings.

Your post here resonated with me so much. I am disabled, like you I have one of those weird awkward disabilities that isn't easily understood (ever wished you could say "I have arthritis..." Or "I have MS"?)

No I don't think they have it easier, no way...no I don't think they are lucky, no I don't have any bitterness...it's not like that. It's just that it's a nice neat easy concept for people to grasp, they get over it and move on. But with something like ME/CFS (I have HMS if you're interested) people go "huh?" then you have to do all the explaining about why you can't work and it's a pain in the ass...and not in the good way;)

So yeah...I've read your blog a few times now and it's something I can relate to. I'm happy about that.

And now, thanks to you I have something else I can check out. That makes me very happy!

So me, my orthotics, my extra pounds and my walking stick want to say thank you. Thank you so much!

Natty said...

Thank you so much, Anonymous. I really enjoyed this comment so much as I can relate with so much. My best friend has MS and there are times I envy him, not only because he's not nearly as sick as I am and there are medications to treat his illness and his doctor knows what's wrong with him, but, yeah, people get that he's seriously ill the minute he says "MS." When I say CFS or ME, it always requires so much explanation, and even then, half the time (at least) I get the sense people only sorta get it.

Oh and I have a walking stick too! :-)